Against a backdrop of modern progress towards same-sex marriage, the 1950s story of two women finding forbidden love in each other has an old-world feel about it. But it is also a beautiful period piece that meticulously re-creates the fine detail of the era. Based on the novel The Price of Salt (1952), it tells the story of the love that could not be mentioned before the sexual revolution and it captures the moral and class tensions of mid-century Manhattan.
Worldly-wise Carol (Cate Blanchett) is the experienced older seductress who is going through a messy divorce and custody battle. She meets shop assistant Therese (Rooney Mara) in an up-market store and the young novice is swept away by the attractive and wealthy socialite. Their love affair inevitably hits male hurdles, and at least some narrative energy is generated not by what happens between Carol and Therese, but between them and the hostile bullies who are husband and boyfriend. The male egos are tortured by the possibility that their women could prefer women, and their attempts to control with veiled aggression put todays domestic violence dispute into an historical frame. The legal system was more brutish and it so favoured men that women had no hope of keeping their children once they were tarnished as “immoral”.
The tension between the acting styles of the two stars is unsettling. Blanchett’s tightly over-controlled emotions appear shallow, even when the two of them are behind closed doors. On the other hand, Mara slides gracefully across a broad emotional spectrum with skilful nuance and natural radiance. It’s a slow story and their only sex scene, far from erotic, is clinical like many of Carol’s responses to Therese. Dut despite star billing, meticulously crafted sets and evocative soft-focus atmospherics, this is one Blanchett film that struggles to inspire.
Director: Todd Haynes
Stars: Cate Blanchett, Rooney Mara
Pingback: A Room in Rome (2010) – CineMuse
Shucks. I kind of liked this one. I felt that Blanchett’s restrained approach was fitting to the times and the role. Perhaps it was a bit overdone. I came here this morning to see if you had reviewed Salt, the 2010 spy thriller with Angelina Jolie. I watched it last night but won’t share my thoughts till you’ve seen it…that is if you’re interested.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I have now posted my review of Salt; its your turn.
No shucks needed Linda; this film is well regarded by many and has several strengths. It may be me, but I felt Blanchett mis-read the role, not mis-played it. But as a period drama it ticks all the boxes. Thanks for suggesting Salt; I now have a copy and will see it next. Also its a lovely idea to suggest a film to someone who enjoys reviewing them. I’ve taken your thought to heart and added a line in my About page to welcome such suggestions.