
Tags
Leave No Trace (2018)
Framing a story through the outlier’s point of view is a self-reflective device that makes us to look at ourselves through the eyes of the marginalised other. It usually adopts a single perspective but Leave No Trace (2018) is as multi-layered as a Russian doll. Homelessness, poverty, single-parenting, post-traumatic stress disorder, and life off-the-grid are just some of the themes woven into this finely balanced film.
The ruggedly beautiful opening scenes show a father and daughter appearing to be camping in the wilderness. Silent but for the sound of nature, they forage, taste nature’s bounty, and communicate by gesture. The father, Will (Ben Foster), is a war veteran with chronic PTSD and cannot stand the confinement of conventional accommodation. His teenage daughter, androgynously named Tom (Thomasin Harcourt McKenzie), has been raised by Will since infancy and is as adept at chess and reading literature as she is at hunting in the wild. They are close, sleep together for warmth, and the forest is their home. That is until a walker spots them and police are brought in.
Immediately applying labels like homeless and potential abusive relationship, the authorities subject them to the kind of interrogation that presumes the worst. We, the audience, are complicit in this process. When suspicion lifts, Will is praised for how well he has raised Tom but they are not permitted to return to their forest home. Social service accommodation is found, but Will soon flees again and Tom must follow. The cycle is repeated until the rapidly maturing Tom must face either a life running from Will’s war torments or claim her independence, put down roots, and let him go.
This film works on all levels. The cinematography has a docu-drama feel, with hand-held camera-work that intimately observes the father and daughter bond. This is pitched perfectly because of the understated authenticity of performance by Foster and McKenzie. It must have been tempting to dramatize the veteran’s trauma but here it is expressed entirely through Foster’s eyes and silent stare. McKenzie consumes her role, emerging from the cocoon of adolescence to a butterfly, vibrant, caring, and grounded in self-belief. The dynamic between them is the scaffold that raises the story beyond expectations.
It would be challenging to find another film that could more appropriately carry the ‘hybrid genre’ label. Strands of adventure story, a coming of age tale, a road trip, and a drama, are all present but none dominate. Nor does the film offer an easy solution to helping people like Tom and Will. This is an engaging and touching tale that leaves a warm glow.
Sydney Film Festival 2018
Director: Debra Granik
Stars: Ben Foster, Thomasin Harcourt McKenzie
Great review, I’m getting the warm and fuzzies just reading it! ☺️ This was on my radar and would definitely be an interesting indie film to catch. Did you watch this at the Sydney film festival recently?
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yes Jolene; I must annotate it as a SFF film. I expect to see it on general release soon.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I didn’t see it because timing didn’t suit!! Should have gone! I saw The Guilty instead on the last day of SFF
LikeLiked by 1 person
Sounds like it has a bit of everything in the storyline. Looking forward to renting it when it becomes available to me.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I saw the previews to this but missed the film. The subject matter reminded me of a film a few years ago. Captain Fantastic, I think. It is a time for oddball dads, I guess.
LikeLiked by 1 person
I recall we chatted about the fable quality of Captain Fantastic. The key themes of Leave No Trace are grounded in realism which makes this film very different. Also Capt Fantastic is a hero-dad while Leave No Trace is a broken soul. Both are great films.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Your mind is a steel trap! I live it. Will try to see this at some point.
LikeLiked by 1 person
At last I’ve seen this film and not a minute too soon. I don’t no how long it will last on the big screen but I imagine a niche audience. I thought it was fantastic! Far better than “Captain Fantastic” mind you, but they’re chalk and cheese.
A film like this proves that you don’t need an excess of words to tell a story, as long as it’s done properly. There was very little dialogue exchanged between father and daughter and yet we understood perfectly.
I loved the silence; with only the sounds of the forest, an occasional bird trilling and sometimes the sound of a radio or guitar player in the background.
Poor Will was irrevocably traumatised by his war background to such an extent he eventually needed to make the ultimate sacrifice and let his daughter go, along with all human contact.
Seeing this film was was a beautiful, profoundly moving experience. Thanks for drawing it to my attention.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Glad you liked it Anita; you have summed it up perfectly.
LikeLike
Thanks Richard. There are other films stemming from the SFF that I’m waiting patiently to see. I hope they all ‘live up’ as this one has.
I think i may have given this 5 stars…well 4.5 to 5.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Yet another insight to add to the volume of my thoughts so far…I enjoy watching films on dealing with ‘inner turmoil’. With this in mind I made comparisons with the film “Tully” as both protagonists ‘had their demons’ and yet each dealt with these in their own way.
Tully’s internal mechanism resulted in hallucinations, whereas Will’s sought to cut himself off from all human contact. I know which method would have been the most satisfactory if treatment were available.
“Leave no Trace” offered a very ‘spare’ script and exposition by telling moments of cinematography. “Tully” on the other hand was full of dialogue and clues regarding what was happening.
Both films did this well, though I suspect “Leave no Trace” pulled it off slightly better. Both leading actors did a commendable job in fleshing out their characters.
Thanks.
LikeLike
I recently managed to find this gem on the internet. It was thought provoking, and agree that it is a very powerful self-reflective device. The flimsiness of human interaction disgusts me and I’ve wondered much about living a semi-nomadic life with only the people that matter to us. It brings to home how truly peaceful I feel when I am on my own and that silence is melody to my ears. Strange huh.🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Not strange at all; you’d be surprised at how many others feel the same. I’m heavily into being alone.
LikeLiked by 1 person
Pingback: Favourites 2018 | CineMuseFilms